The Man from Earth: Holocene is a thought-provoking continuation of the cult classic science fiction film The Man from Earth. Released in 2017, this sequel picks up a decade after the original, revisiting the mysterious life of John Oldman, a man who has lived for over 14,000 years. While the first film focused primarily on dialogue and philosophical speculation, Holocene deepens the narrative by introducing new characters, exploring broader themes, and hinting at the consequences of immortality in a modern world. This sequel retains the intimate, character-driven style that fans appreciated in the original while offering new angles and moral dilemmas.
Background and Premise
The Legacy of the Original
The Man from Earth (2007) was a low-budget but high-concept film written by renowned science fiction writer Jerome Bixby. It featured a group of academics listening to their colleague, John Oldman, as he reveals his secret: he has lived for thousands of years, having survived through every major period of human history. The film’s appeal came from its intellectual dialogue and minimalist storytelling, making it a favorite among science fiction fans who appreciate philosophical depth.
Transitioning to Holocene
The Man from Earth: Holocene continues this narrative, but shifts focus slightly. John Oldman, now going by the name John Young, has taken up a quiet life as a college professor. However, signs indicate that something is changing within him. Unlike the static immortality he previously experienced, he now begins to show signs of aging. At the same time, a group of curious students uncovers his past, setting off a new chain of revelations and challenges.
Cast and Character Development
David Lee Smith as John Oldman / John Young
David Lee Smith returns to portray the central character, once again delivering a calm, grounded performance that anchors the film. John is a character filled with wisdom and quiet sorrow, having lived through centuries of human evolution, loss, and transformation. In Holocene, Smith expands upon the character’s depth, showing subtle vulnerability as John faces his possible mortality.
New Student Characters
Unlike the original, which focused primarily on older academics, Holocene introduces a younger cast of college students. These students become suspicious of John’s mysterious past and begin an investigation. This narrative change allows the film to explore intergenerational dialogue and how younger minds approach truth, belief, and skepticism in the digital age.
- Philip Michael as Tariq: A skeptical and tech-savvy student who becomes instrumental in uncovering John’s past.
- Akemi Look as Isabel: A deeply curious and empathetic student who begins to form a personal connection with John.
- Sterling Knight as Steve: A science enthusiast who brings a rational perspective to the group’s search for answers.
The students’ involvement adds tension and narrative drive, contrasting their youthful curiosity with John’s ancient weariness.
Themes and Philosophical Exploration
Immortality and Identity
The central theme of Holocene remains immortality, but it is examined through a new lens. Unlike the first film, which reveled in John’s past experiences, this sequel explores what it means when immortality might be slipping away. John’s subtle signs of aging raise profound questions about identity, loss, and the passage of time. If he is no longer immortal, who is he now? What becomes of a man who has defined himself by his endless journey through history?
Faith, Myth, and Science
Another key element in the story is the interplay between myth and science. The students’ discovery of John’s secret stirs debate about belief versus evidence, much like the original film. In Holocene, these discussions are more grounded in modern digital culture, including internet research, viral content, and rapid communication. This introduces a new layer: how would society react if a man claimed to be thousands of years old today?
Moral Responsibility
John’s awareness of how his knowledge might affect others leads to deeper ethical discussions. Should he reveal his identity if it could change people’s perception of life, religion, or human history? Is it right to keep such a secret, or is it safer to remain hidden? These dilemmas form the heart of the film’s drama, elevating it beyond mere sci-fi speculation.
Storytelling Style and Atmosphere
Minimalist Aesthetic
Much like its predecessor, The Man from Earth: Holocene relies heavily on dialogue, character interaction, and internal conflict rather than flashy effects or action scenes. This minimalism allows viewers to focus on the ideas and emotional resonance of each scene. The film’s settings classrooms, homes, quiet outdoor landscapes reflect the introspective mood of the narrative.
Emotional Tension
As the students dig deeper into John’s identity, the tension grows, not through violence or confrontation, but through intellectual discovery and emotional shifts. John’s attempts to protect his secret clash with the students’ determination to uncover the truth, resulting in scenes that feel both personal and universally reflective.
Reception and Cultural Impact
Fan Reactions
Though it did not have a wide theatrical release, Holocene gained attention online, especially among fans of the original. Some appreciated its continuation of thought-provoking dialogue and philosophical inquiry, while others found the slower pace a challenge. However, the film stayed true to its roots, appealing to viewers who value character-driven science fiction.
Streaming and Accessibility
The release of Holocene was unconventional. It was made available through online platforms, with some of the creators even encouraging viewers to share the film freely to reach wider audiences. This approach matched the indie spirit of the original and helped it find a niche audience despite limited marketing.
Continuing the Series
Rumors and discussions about a third installment in The Man from Earth series have circulated among fans. Given the unresolved questions at the end of Holocene, there is potential for further exploration of John’s fate, his past, and his place in the modern world. The filmmakers have left the door open for future philosophical journeys with this unique character.
A Quiet but Powerful Sequel
The Man from Earth: Holocene may not cater to mainstream blockbuster tastes, but it offers a deeply human, emotionally intelligent exploration of what it means to live and possibly die after centuries of existence. With a compelling lead in David Lee Smith, a thoughtful script, and themes that stretch from history to morality, the film invites viewers to reflect on time, knowledge, and what it means to be truly alive.
Its quiet power lies in conversation and contemplation, making it a rare gem in the realm of modern science fiction. Whether you’re revisiting the story of John Oldman or encountering it for the first time, Holocene presents a unique and moving experience that continues to challenge our understanding of humanity and time itself.